Fair disclaimer: None of this is my personal experience, I'm writing this because I have to explain to people several times a month that their issues are not caused by Conay, but by their server hosting.
And because just today I had to explain it to 3 separate people, I decided to write this article, so next time I can just send them this instead.
There's so many providers that offer hosting of Conan Exiles servers, and most of them are terrible. I won't list them, there's so many. I will only name one and that is G-portal, because Funcom is promoting them directly in the game, and therefore it definitely deserves our scrutiny.
So why is G-portal (and many other similar providers) terrible for hosting modded Conan Exiles servers?
It has a lot to do with how they handle mods. The game client uses modlist.txt with full paths that include both Workshop IDs and .pak names.
The official DedicatedServerLauncher made by Funcom works the same way and also has built-in auto updates and can automatically restart your server whenever there is a mod update.
These things are the standard.
Yet, many go for the simplest solution - hosting providers that require no setup, that seem to be user-friendly, and I understand that. But it's going to cause you more headaches than it's worth.
In the end, renting a dedicated server machine and installing the DedicatedServerLauncher on it is the only way I'd recommend going about this. You need to be in control.
Only then (or with some rare exceptions of game server hostings that do it right) the server functions the way it's intended. It's quite funny, how a hosting promoted by Funcom doesn't abide by the intended way Conan mods are handled. That's why you'll also hear other modders complain about these hostings as well. Because players complain to them that their mods are not updating correctly and what not, while it's a hosting problem.
What issues does bad hosting cause?
The specific one I get upset about is what I mentioned above, not using standard format modlist.txt - because that often causes ConaySync to not work.
Let's say that there's a mod internally named HelloWorld.pak and it exists on Legacy with one Workshop ID, then the author abandoned it and allowed someone to reupload it, which has a second Workshop ID but the same pak file name, and then the author came back and made an Enhanced version of the mod with a third Workshop ID but still the same pak file name.
Now, if you're using a hosting that only saves pak file names, it will cause issues - including not being able to tell ConaySync what Workshop ID is it using. Conay relies on that. If your server doesn't have that data, because the hosting hides it from it, then there's a problem.
And because my background services have no idea which mod of the three it actually is, it will try to guess, and it might guess wrong, and your players will get errors or get stuck in a mod mismatch loop, and blame me and my launcher.
Are there other issues? Oh, yes, many. Just look up "G-portal" (or your other hosting name) in the Conan Exiles Modding, Admins United: Conan, or Tot ! Mods Discord server, and you will see many (I dare say hundreds of) posts asking about various issues and the conclusion simply being - these hosting providers do not care about good service for modded servers.
I've also heard of many people who contacted the support of their hosting, trying to resolve these issues, but they were always ignored, or told it works as intended.
And don't get me started on all the servers that don't auto update their mods because their hosting doesn't support it, and so their admins do it manually and then ping everyone each time they have to restart, with a screenshot from their hosting provider's web interface saying there's a mod to update. And if you try to connect in between the update being out and them manually restarting the server, you won't even get to play until then. Ugh.
But I insist on using this hosting - what do I do to make it work with Conay?
Completely fair, perhaps they have great prices, or you are not tech-savvy enough to host it on a dedicated server, and all the other hosting providers suck ass as well.
Or you simply don't want to go through the headache of changing a hosting after you already paid for this one and set it all up as it is. Very understandable.
Here's what you wanna do:
- Connect to the server without Conay, just let the game auto-restart to sort your mods.
- Open the
modlist.txton your computer, not the one on the server, since it's missing critical information that Conay needs to know. - Copy the contents of the file.
- Paste it into the modlist field on this website when editing the server.
- Make sure it works with Conay now.
That's it.
It's not a complicated thing to fix, it is just something that's confusing for players and server owners, not knowing why it's happening. So here you have it.
I also updated the background services of Conay to try to guess the mod IDs in a smarter way now (differentiating between Legacy and Enhanced versions in the cache), it may solve it for some mods and some hostings, but not for all. It doesn't solve the underlying issue, it's just a little guy's makeshift patch on a highway pothole.
Hopefully it works for some and they don't have to experience these issues, read this article, and get as frustrated as I get about it.
At this point, given what I've been writing about on this blog so far, I feel like an old man yelling at clouds. But there will quite likely be more of it. Because we can make things right.